(267) 481-5636
    Randy Henrick & Associates, L.L.C.
    • Home
    • Services
    • Special Offers
    • About Us/Contact
    • Blog

    ​

    Blogs

    The CFPB Arbitration Rule:  Risky but not Likely to Take Effect

    7/11/2017

    0 Comments

     
    The federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (“CFPB”) published its final rule on consumer arbitration and class action waiver clauses this week. The rule, which would take effect 241 days after being published in the Federal Register, effectively prohibits the use of arbitration clauses that waive a consumer’s right to participate in a class action for essentially any consumer finance transaction including auto finance. The CFPB itself estimates the rule will cause $2.6 billion to $5.2 billion to defend class actions over the next five years.

    Despite CFPB Director Richard Cordray’s fanfare in announcing the rule for the alleged protection of consumers (even though the CFPB’s own study revealed that it is class action plaintiffs’ lawyers who make windfalls on fees in class actions with class members getting little of the final ante), I’m betting the rule will never take effect.

    First, the Congressional Review Act (“CRA”) gives the Congress an expedited procedure for a simple majority with no filibustering to overturn any federal administrative agency rule or regulation for a period of 60 in-session days. Once signed by the President, the rule is repealed and the agency cannot enact anything similar.

    Congressional legislation to reign in the CFPB has also been active independently on Capitol Hill. Representative Hensarling’s bill would fund the CFPB through the Congressional appropriations process, and eliminate its UDAAP and supervisory authority, among other restrictions. To add a clause negating the arbitration rule would seem a fairly simple matter.

    Even if Congress doesn’t act, the American Banker reported the U.S. Chamber of Commerce will sue the CFPB on the arbitration rule 241 days after Federal Register publication. They have a number of compelling legal and Constitutional arguments that likely would result in a judge granting a preliminary injunction against the rule while the Court sorts it out. Cordray’s tenure as CFPB Director expires three months thereafter and his successor nominated by President Trump could be expected to revoke the rule even while the preliminary injunction lawsuit was pending.

    Already, auto industry and consumer finance lobbying groups have indicated they will lobby their Congress people to use the CRA or enact other legislation to undo the arbitration rule. They too could bring or join lawsuits against it that could delay its effect until after Cordray leaves. I think the likelihood of the rule surviving Corday are not very high.

    So you have multiple constituents, a favorable Congress, and a number of avenues to seek a repeal or overturn the arbitration rule. There is no need for panic. A call to your House and Senate representatives and trade association activity yes. If we are diligent in opposition, it is very unlikely that this rule—arguably Cordray’s last ditch effort to get at auto dealers—will ever see the light of day.
    0 Comments



    Leave a Reply.

      Author

      Randy Henrick is a leading auto industry compliance consultant. This article is not intended as legal or compliance advice due to the unique nature of a dealer's situation in each state. Randy's articles do provide issues and best practices that you may want to discuss with your attorney or compliance advisor for possible adoption in your dealership. Email Randy at AutoDealerCompliance@gmail.com
      Follow us on Twitter @randyh44

      Archives

      January 2021
      August 2020
      July 2020
      May 2020
      March 2020
      January 2020
      December 2019
      October 2019
      August 2019
      June 2019
      April 2019
      March 2019
      February 2019
      January 2019
      November 2018
      October 2018
      August 2018
      June 2018
      May 2018
      February 2018
      December 2017
      October 2017
      September 2017
      July 2017
      May 2017
      March 2017
      January 2017
      December 2016
      November 2016
      October 2016
      September 2016
      August 2016
      June 2016
      May 2016
      April 2016

      RSS Feed

    © 2018 Randy Henrick & Associates, L.L.C.
    Back to top